Plymouth Cheddar Cheese

Historic raw milk cheddar with a full-bodied profile, balanced cream, and a clean tang.

Original Plymouth Cheddar is a one-year aged raw cow milk cheese made from a historic recipe dating back to the late 1800s. It delivers a full-bodied flavor with a balanced mix of creaminess and tang, finishing clean with a lingering sharpness. The texture is firm but approachable, making it easy to slice for boards or enjoy on its own.

This is a classic cheddar built in the English tradition, offering a straightforward, well-structured flavor that works across everyday use and simple entertaining. It is reliable, versatile, and rooted in a style that has stood the test of time.

Product Details

Type: Cheddar Cheese
Milk: Raw Cow Milk
Aged: 1 Year
Size: 8 oz. Waxed Block
Style: English-style heritage cheddar
Origin: Plymouth, Vermont

Meet The Maker

Plymouth Cheese has been producing cheddar in Plymouth, Vermont since 1890, founded by the family of President Calvin Coolidge. The creamery continues to use a traditional granular curd method and waxed packaging that reflects its original process. Today, the cheese is still made in the same historic factory, preserving a direct connection to one of the oldest cheddar traditions in the United States. The result is a heritage product built on consistency, craftsmanship, and time-honored technique.